Naslov
Free Deliberation

Autori
Pećnjak, Davor

Vrsta, podvrsta i kategorija rada
Poglavlja u knjigama, znanstveni

Knjiga
Free Will and Action: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives

Urednik/ci
Grgić, Filip, Pećnjak, Davor

Izdavač
Springer

Grad
Cham

Godina
2018

Raspon stranica
39-46

ISBN
978-3-319-99294-5

Ključne riječi
God, Actish phenomenal feeling ; Deliberation, Determinism, Freedom

Sažetak
In the first part of this article, I expose what does it mean for an agent to deliberate about some future action. Since deliberation is a mental event, or series of mental events, it is therefore a kind of action also. I show then, that under the supposition that determinism is the case, then deliberation, in its usual sense, does not exist. But, this is not acceptable. Deliberation, to be a real source of free action, itself has to be free, or form of a free (mental) action. Steps in human deliberating must not be inevitable products of laws of nature and a certain (initial) state of the universe. In the second part of the article I offer a theistic argument for libertarian freedom of the will and freedom of the action. Most people has a very strong feeling that unil time t they can do A or that they can refrain, until t, from doing A, and that they can deliberate intentionally about what to do, weighing reasons for and against doing A. Concerning God, God is a perfect being. God does not, therefore lie and He is not a deceiver. God created human beings who have strong intuition that they can do A or not-A at t, and since God is not a deceiver, that intuition must be truthful. So, human beings posses free will in libertarian sense and they can deliberate genuinely freely.

Izvorni jezik
Engleski

Znanstvena područja
Filozofija

POVEZANOST RADA