Naslov
Rule(s) of Recognition and Canons of Interpretation

Autori
Burazin, Luka ; Ratti, Giovanni Battista

Vrsta, podvrsta i kategorija rada
Poglavlja u knjigama, znanstveni

Knjiga
Judges and Adjudication in Constitutional Democracies: A View from Legal Realism

Urednik/ci
Chiassoni, Pierluigi ; Spaić, Bojan

Izdavač
Springer

Grad
Dordrecht

Godina
2021

Raspon stranica
123-138

ISBN
978-3-030-58185-5

ISSN
1572-4395

Ključne riječi
rule of recognition, interpretation, positivism, realism

Sažetak
It is sometimes claimed (in Anglo-American jurisprudential literature) that the rule of recognition sets the criteria for identifying legal norms and that this, therefore, means that canons of interpretation are also part of these criteria. Such a view then faces the problem of theoretical disagreements that call into question the rule of recognition itself and legal positivistic accounts of law. The paper argues that the rule of recognition sets the criteria only for sources of law and not legal norms themselves and that a theory of interpretation that distinguishes between normative texts (sources of law) and legal norms (as meanings of legal texts) can help explain why the rule of recognition might still be conceived as a conventional rule based on the convergent practice of officials and the fact that officials sometimes disagree about the correct interpretation of legal texts.

Izvorni jezik
Engleski

Znanstvena područja
Pravo

POVEZANOST RADA