Naslov
Children's Rights in European Legal Preceedings: Why are Family Practices so Different from Legal Theories?

Autori
Rešetar, Branka ; Emery, E. Robert

Izvornik
Family Court Review (1531-2445) 46 (2008), 1; 65-78

Vrsta, podvrsta i kategorija rada
Radovi u časopisima, članak, znanstveni

Ključne riječi
European law ; divorce ; children's rights ; comparative law ; family law

Sažetak
Debates about child custody following parental separation often have been framed in terms of a battle between the competing rights of different family members. In the United States, advocates of mothers’ rights square off against proponents of fathers’ rights, with each side claiming to truly represent children’ s rights. Of course, not all advocates lay claim to children’ s rights in contact and custody disputes merely as a tactical maneuver. Some experts believe that children are entitled to (and benefit from) their own, independent legal advocate in custody cases. In theory, at least, the position that children lay claim to a third set of independent rights is strongly held in Europe, more strongly than in many U.S. states, because of the adoption of United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child in Europe, but not in the United States. In this article, we examine children’ s rights in custody disputes from a European perspective, particularly children’ s legal right to contact with their parents, as well as the children’ s right to be heard in custody and contact disputes. We find that, despite differences in legal theory, tradition, and family demographics, European countries ultimately face a familiar reality: Custody and contact disputes are, in reality, more about renegotiating family relationships than they are a matter of a mother’ s, father’ s, or child’ s rights.

Izvorni jezik
Engleski

Znanstvena područja
Pravo

POVEZANOST RADA