Napredna pretraga

Pregled bibliografske jedinice broj: 1028804

• Do Judicial Decision-Making and Quantum Mechanics Have Anything in Common? A Contribution to Realist Theories of Adjudication at the CJEU


Ćapeta, Tamara
• Do Judicial Decision-Making and Quantum Mechanics Have Anything in Common? A Contribution to Realist Theories of Adjudication at the CJEU // The Role of Courts in Contemporary Legal Orders / Belov, Martin (ur.).
Hag: Eleven I terminational Publishing, 2019. str. 83-98


Naslov
• Do Judicial Decision-Making and Quantum Mechanics Have Anything in Common? A Contribution to Realist Theories of Adjudication at the CJEU

Autori
Ćapeta, Tamara

Vrsta, podvrsta i kategorija rada
Poglavlja u knjigama, ostalo

Knjiga
The Role of Courts in Contemporary Legal Orders

Urednik/ci
Belov, Martin

Izdavač
Eleven I terminational Publishing

Grad
Hag

Godina
2019

Raspon stranica
83-98

ISBN
978-94-6236-920-7

Ključne riječi
CJEU, judicial interpretation. adjudication, legal realism, quantum mechanics

Sažetak
Is judicial decision-making a science or an art? The debate on the question of what happens in the judicial process is often termed in this way. It reflects the difference between legal formalists and legal realists in their descriptions of judicial decision-making. In a nutshell, the former see judging as an objective system which judges follow, whereas the latter see it as a more intuitive process. Therefore, the comparison with science aims to say that judging is not based on the subjective point of view of judges. This contribution questions this proposal, and claim that the way in which legal realists explain judicial decision-making can also be explained by using science as a comparator. From this perspective, it makes a parallel between judicial decision-making and quantum physics.

Izvorni jezik
Engleski

Znanstvena područja
Interdisciplinarne prirodne znanosti, Pravo



POVEZANOST RADA


Ustanove
Pravni fakultet, Zagreb

Profili:

Avatar Url Tamara Ćapeta (autor)

Citiraj ovu publikaciju

Ćapeta, Tamara
• Do Judicial Decision-Making and Quantum Mechanics Have Anything in Common? A Contribution to Realist Theories of Adjudication at the CJEU // The Role of Courts in Contemporary Legal Orders / Belov, Martin (ur.).
Hag: Eleven I terminational Publishing, 2019. str. 83-98
Ćapeta, T. (2019) • Do Judicial Decision-Making and Quantum Mechanics Have Anything in Common? A Contribution to Realist Theories of Adjudication at the CJEU. U: Belov, M. (ur.) The Role of Courts in Contemporary Legal Orders. Hag, Eleven I terminational Publishing, str. 83-98.
@inbook{inbook, author = {\'{C}apeta, T.}, editor = {Belov, M.}, year = {2019}, pages = {83-98}, keywords = {CJEU, judicial interpretation. adjudication, legal realism, quantum mechanics}, isbn = {978-94-6236-920-7}, title = {• Do Judicial Decision-Making and Quantum Mechanics Have Anything in Common? A Contribution to Realist Theories of Adjudication at the CJEU}, keyword = {CJEU, judicial interpretation. adjudication, legal realism, quantum mechanics}, publisher = {Eleven I terminational Publishing}, publisherplace = {Hag} }